Table A-3. Summary of Assessment of Practicability of Alternatives

(1991 and 1993 Federal Compliance Evaluations)

Alternative Considered

Year Evaluated

Determination

Rationale
24 NLP 1991, 1993 Practicable Meets basic and overall purposes at reasonable cost
24 NLP/Desal 1993 Practicable Meets basic and overall purposes at reasonable cost
16 NLP/Desal 1991 Practicable/not practicable Met basic purpose in 1991; changes in instream flow requirements by agencies resulted in need for larger reservoir
9 NLP/Desal 1991 Not practicable Other significant adverse consequences; does not comply with 40 CFR 230.10(a); may fail to meet basic purpose
23 NSC 1991 Practicable/not practicable Met basic purpose in 1991; later agency determinations rendered it infeasible
6 CAC/Desal 1991 Not practicable Outside MPWMD boundary; other significant adverse consequences; does not comply with 40 CFR 230.10(a)
11 SCC 1991 Not practicable Fails to meet basic project purpose
10 CHU 1991 Not practicable Fails to meet basic project purpose; outside MPWMD boundary
25 CAN 1993 Not practicable Extremely high cost; other significant adverse consequences; does not comply with 40 CFR 230.10(a)
15 CAN/Desal 1993 Not practicable Cost uncertainties attributable to technical concerns; fails to meet overall purpose; logistical factors
7 DSL 1991, 1993 Not practicable Excessively high cost for incremental water benefit; cost uncertainty resulting from energy costs; partially outside MPWMD boundary; fails to meet overall purpose
No project 1991, 1993 Not practicable Fails to meet basic and overall purposes


Source: MPWMD 1995f.