|
Alternative Considered |
Year Evaluated |
Determination |
Rationale |
|
24 NLP |
1991, 1993 |
Practicable |
Meets basic and overall purposes at reasonable
cost |
|
24 NLP/Desal |
1993 |
Practicable |
Meets basic and overall purposes at reasonable
cost |
|
16 NLP/Desal |
1991 |
Practicable/not practicable |
Met basic purpose in 1991; changes in instream
flow requirements by agencies resulted in need for larger reservoir |
|
9 NLP/Desal |
1991 |
Not practicable |
Other significant adverse consequences; does
not comply with 40 CFR 230.10(a); may fail to meet basic purpose |
|
23 NSC |
1991 |
Practicable/not practicable |
Met basic purpose in 1991; later agency determinations
rendered it infeasible |
|
6 CAC/Desal |
1991 |
Not practicable |
Outside MPWMD boundary; other significant adverse
consequences; does not comply with 40 CFR 230.10(a) |
|
11 SCC |
1991 |
Not practicable |
Fails to meet basic project purpose |
|
10 CHU |
1991 |
Not practicable |
Fails to meet basic project purpose; outside
MPWMD boundary |
|
25 CAN |
1993 |
Not practicable |
Extremely high cost; other significant adverse
consequences; does not comply with 40 CFR 230.10(a) |
|
15 CAN/Desal |
1993 |
Not practicable |
Cost uncertainties attributable to technical
concerns; fails to meet overall purpose; logistical factors |
|
7 DSL |
1991, 1993 |
Not practicable |
Excessively high cost for incremental water benefit;
cost uncertainty resulting from energy costs; partially outside
MPWMD boundary; fails to meet overall purpose |
|
No project |
1991, 1993 |
Not practicable |
Fails to meet basic and overall purposes |