Table A-1. Ratings for Alternatives Considered
in Part I Screening

Alternative Pass
Conditional
Pass*
Fail
Carmel River Mainstem Dams      
New San Clemente - Roller-compacted concrete

 X
   
New San Clemente - Rockfill    

X
New San Clemente - Joint use    

X
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers proposals      
  • San Clemente site
  •    

    X
  • Cachagua site
  •    

    X
  • Pine Creek site
  •    

    X
  • Klondike site
  •    

    X
  • Los Padres
  •    

    X
    Enlarged Los Padres

     X
       
    Carmel River Tributary Dams      
    San Clemente Creek variations

    X
       
    Cachagua Creek variations  

    X
     
    Chupines Creek variations  

    X
     
    Buckeye Creek variations    

    X
    Sediment Removal      
    Los Padres Reservoir

    X
       
    San Clemente Reservoir

    X
       
    Storage and Infiltration Basins/Recharge      
    Fort Ord depressions    

    X
    Seaside Groundwater Recharge - Coastal barrier    

    X
    Seaside Coastal Groundwater Subbasins - Recharge with wells    

    X
    Groundwater Development      
    Seaside Coastal Groundwater Subbasins well development

    X
       
    Seaside Inland Groundwater Subbasin well development    

    X
    Upper Carmel Valley well development

    X
       
    Lower Carmel Valley well development

    X
       
    Importation of Water from Distant Sources      
    Arroyo Seco River    

    X
    Lower Salinas Basin    

    X
    San Felipe project    

    X
    Big and Little Sur Rivers    

    X
    Desalination  

    X
     
    Wastewater Reclamation      
    Used for groundwater recharge    

    X
    Use of Monterey treatment facility  

    X
     
    Irrigation of Del Monte Forest golf courses

    X
       
    Conservation      
    Residential and institutional cisterns    

    X
    Comprehensive program including mandatory retrofit

     X
       

     * Conditional Pass - Additional information may result in subsequent determination that this alternative fails to satisfy Part I screening criteria.

    Source: MPWMD 1994a.